Eternals Movie Review

Alt = Official theatrical poster for Eternals 2021. Image: Marvel Studios / Walt Disney Studios Motion PicturesEternals Movie Review
Official theatrical poster for Eternals 2021. Image: Marvel Studios / Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

Introduction (Warning Contains Spoilers)

With Avengers: Doomsday out in December, I thought it would be a good idea to continue my chronological journey through the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

As I have already watched all the movies that lead up to Avengers: Endgame, I want to take a look at what has happened since. I will now be looking at is Eternals, directed by Chloé Zhao.

Eternals is the 26th movie in the MCU and takes a huge step away from the typical Marvel formula. This time it focuses on a brand new group of immortal characters.

The story spans thousands of years and looks into themes such as humanity, creation, loyalty and the meaning of life.

It has an incredible cast including Gemma Chan, Richard Madden, Angelina Jolie and Salma Hayek. Along with Kumail Nanjiani, Brian Tyree Henry, Barry Keoghan and Kit Harington. It was directed by award winning director Chloé Zhao.

There are many good aspects to this film, like the cinematography and exploration of philosophies. However, the film has huge ambitions which leads to some issues.

This makes it one of the most visually unique Marvel movies, but also very divisive

A New Chapter in the Marvel Cinematic Universe

Thousands of years ago, the Celestial Arishem sent ten immortal beings to Earth to protect humans from the threat of Deviants.

Over the years the Eternals have been integrated into human history. However, they are prohibited from getting involved with humans due to their incredible powers. They have lived for so long that they have very different opinions on humans.

In the present day after Avengers: Endgame, the Deviants reappear causing the Eternals to come back together after many years. However, they quickly find out that their mission has become a lot more complex.

They learn they were sent to Earth for a reason that is much bigger than they first thought and questions their whole beliefs.

The premise of this story provides many opportunities. A whole new mythology is introduced which will help expand the MCU. However, there is a lot of information to try fit into one story.

Introducing the Eternals
Alt = Kumail Nanjiani, Lauren Ridloff, Ma Dong-seok, Angelina Jolie, Richard Madden, Salma Hayek, Gemma Chan, Lia McHugh, Brian Tyree and Barry Keoghan star in the Eternals (2021) ©Marvel Studios / Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
Kumail Nanjiani, Lauren Ridloff, Ma Dong-seok, Angelina Jolie, Richard Madden, Salma Hayek, Gemma Chan, Lia McHugh, Brian Tyree and Barry Keoghan star in the Eternals (2021) ©Marvel Studios / Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

A major challenge in this movie was having 10 immortal heroes all at once. However, one character does not get sufficient development.

Gemma Chan plays Sersi. She is an empathic and a powerful matter manipulator. She becomes the heart of the story. As she cares for humans it also makes her an important character for the main conflict.

Richard Madden plays Ikaris, a powerful Eternal capable of flight and firing cosmic energy beams. His relationship with Sersi becomes central to the narrative. However, his character’s motivations are not always explored convincingly.

Angelina Jolie portrays Thena, an exceptional warrior who creates weapons from cosmic energy. She suffers from a condition affecting her memories and behaviour. Jolie brings considerable intensity to the role.

Ajak is played by Salma Hayek. Ajak is the group’s spiritual leader and has amazing healing powers that connect to the Celestials. She brings some great warmth and strength to the character.

Kingo is played by Kumail Nanjiani. He has become a Bollywood star but still secretly carries his Eternal identity. He brings some great entertainment with his larger than life personality.

Sprite is played by Lia McHugh. Sprite is an Eternal with the ability to create realistic illusions. She has an ancient mind but struggles to escape her youthful looks.

Phastos is played by Brian Tyree Henry. Phastos is a genius inventor who has helped progress human technology.

He brings an important personal element to the movie. He is one of the most emotional characters.

Makkari is played by Lauren Ridloff. Makkari is the fastest woman in the universe. Her relationship with Druig (played by Barry Keoghan) brings some of the calmer moments of the film. Druig has the power to control minds which bring some complex moral questions.

The strongest member of the group, Gilgamesh is played by Don Lee. He is a loyal bodyguard to Thena and their relationship brings some of the most emotional moments.

Dane Whitman is played by Kit Harington. He is a museum curator and has a romantic relationship with Sersi. His role isn’t huge but it adds another link to the Marvel universe.

Overall the cast are incredible but there are too many characters to really develop them. Some of the Eternals are much more memorable than others.

Chloé Zhao’s Distinctive Direction
Alt = Richard Madden and Director Chloé Zhao On The Set Of Eternals (2021) Photo by Sophie Mutevelian ©Marvel Studios / Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
Richard Madden and Director Chloé Zhao On The Set Of Eternals (2021) Photo by Sophie Mutevelian ©Marvel Studios / Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

It was an interesting choice to bring Chloé Zhao on board. Following the success of Nomadland, she brought a very different filmmaking sensibility to the superhero genre.

She uses natural acting, real locations and meditative storytelling which creates a unique feel to Eternals. It often feels more like an epic fantasy than your typical Marvel movie.

This is especially effective during the more character driven scenes. The Eternals have seen thousands of years of human history and there are plenty of opportunities for them to reflect on life, love and accountability.

The movie also benefits from it being willing to question the moral standards we usually associate with superheroes.

The main theme of the movie focuses around accountability, belief and free will and there is no clear good vs bad.

However, Zhao’s meditative style does not always fit well with the blockbuster style we expect from Marvel. The movie constantly moves between deep conversations and epic action scenes.

Overall the direction is very ambitious but can feel a little disjointed. If the story had been tighter we may have seen more of Zhao’s strengths on show.

Stunning Cinematography and Visual Ambition
Alt = Angelina Jolie in the Eternals (2021) ©Marvel Studios / Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
Angelina Jolie in the Eternals (2021) ©Marvel Studios / Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

One of the best aspects of Eternals is the cinematography, Ben Davis produces beautiful and vast landscapes.

The movie was filmed in a variety of different locations, the Canary Islands and the English countryside help give it a unique visual style.

Zhao often uses natural light in his scenes which really works well. Many scenes use the warm lighting of the sun rising and setting.

Alt = Eternals (2021) Image: Marvel Studios / Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures
Eternals (2021) Image: Marvel Studios / Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

This gives a very artistic feel to the scenes and helps the characters to feel like they belong with the environment.

The visuals help emphasise the vast time period. The ancient civilisations, natural landscapes and modern cities give a realistic feeling of the passage of time. It feels like a much bigger world than the streets we are used to seeing the Avengers on.

Unfortunately the visual effects are not as consistent. The realistic landscapes are mixed with complex cosmic visuals and digital creatures. Sometimes it can be difficult for them to fit together.

The Celestials are stunning, their massive size helps to show how incredible the story is. However some of the Deviant designs and energy do not have much weight to them.

Because the cinematography is so realistic you can see the contrast. The practical visuals all feel very real however some of the digital ones do not.

Overall the visuals are stunning. The landscapes and composition give a fresh change from the usual digital environments we see in Marvel movies.

An Overloaded Storyline

The issues with Eternals is that the story is very long. With a runtime of 2 hours and 36 minutes there was plenty of time to delve into this mythology.

With ten new heroes to introduce, there is a lot for the script to do. Introduce the Deviants, the Celestials and show how they have evolved throughout the thousands of years. Then it all ties together into one epic battle.

The time travel elements are quite nice but make for some breaks in the flow.

For people who are not familiar with this story, the mythology can be confusing. There are so many new ideas introduced that are not always given the time they need to be explained. This makes some aspects feel unnecessarily complicated.

The original Avengers benefitted by introducing each hero in different movies. People had a good understanding of who they were and what their motivations were. Eternals needed to do this in one movie.

This leads to the issue with the characters. Although we want the audience to get attached to these ten characters and their complex relationships, some of them do not get the development they need.

The main conflict lacks any real flow. The main issue is that while the struggle between obeying orders and saving humanity is interesting, some of the betrayals and ideological conflicts were not well set up emotionally.

The main issue with the main character being Sersi is that while her empathy is what gives the movie its morality, she is quite passive and does not jump out at you like Kingo or Druig.

The movie had some interesting ideas but they were not given the time they deserved. A TV show could have been a good idea so that they could have given each Eternal their own episode to show their past and relationships.

A Different Kind of Marvel Superhero Story

Eternals tries something different despite its problems. It has some great themes that set it apart from many of the MCU adventures.

The film makes you think about whether humankind are worthy of existing. As the Eternals have seen incredible feats and horrific suffering, they have to consider if humanity is worth it.

Belief and meaning are important elements. The characters have to rethink their beliefs and learn that their purpose may not be what they thought.

There is also some interesting consequences regarding blind loyalty. While following orders may seem simple, when they go against your morals it can be an issue. The Eternals have to decide if they should be loyal to their creators.

It gives the story a deeper feel. However, the film occasionally explains its philosophical ideas too directly.

However, the film occasionally explains its philosophical ideas too directly. Some discussions feel more like exposition than natural conversations. A little more subtlety might have made these themes considerably more effective.

Final Verdict

Eternals remains one of Marvel’s most fascinating experiments. Its stunning cinematography, ambitious mythology and distinctive direction deserve appreciation.

However, an overloaded story and underdeveloped characters prevent it from reaching its considerable potential.